websights

Fill out the form to download

Required field
Required field
Not a valid email address
Required field
Required field

SRE Uses Urban Microclimate Analysis for Planning

SRE is one of the UK’s leading sustainability consultancies. Founded in 2005, with a vision to ensure the built environment enhances life without costing the earth, SRE has been at the forefront of the drive to raise the environmental performance of buildings from the start. SRE has worked with more than 500 clients on over 2,900 residential, mixed-use and commercial projects across the UK. Their loyal client base includes architects, planners, developers and surveyors. With over 45 different sustainability services, SRE is a one-stop shop when it comes to meeting the sustainability requirements of your development or property portfolio.

Simulation for Accelerating Planning Approvals

Core services include planning, compliance, and performance-based design and operation services for buildings and cities. SRE provides its clients with four key service offerings including energy and environmental design, building physics, sustainability strategies, and planning and compliance for building regulations and planning policies. They work with architects, contractors, and developers on all types of new and existing buildings including commercial, healthcare, education, and residential. SRE leverages engineering simulation to deliver wind-related risk and planning compliance for new building projects and urban developments.

Nikolaos Protogeros, Technical Director at SRE, leads a team of building physics consultants who make extensive use of specialist software design tools. Their main modeling tasks include using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) for wind comfort and building aerodynamics, natural ventilation design, indoor air quality, and thermal comfort predictions. They have recently extended the use of CFD and SimScale tools for building thermal analysis looking at thermal bridging and the prediction of PSI values.

The team has developed CAD and modeling workflows that make use of Rhino®/Grasshopper extensively and Sketchup. Both Rhino® and Sketchup® have easy import workflows into SimScale making it a seamless process to apply CFD more readily. One of the benefits most often cited by SimScale users is the little or no geometry cleanup required to use the powerful lattice Boltzmann method (LBM) solver Pacefish©, integrated into SimScale for external wind analysis. SRE has been working on several projects in cities across the UK, including London where planning permission requires wind comfort assessments before the Greater London Authority (GLA) can grant planning consent. The pedestrian wind comfort (PWC) tool in SimScale is ideal for these tasks as much of the workflow is automated including setup and results processing and visualization.

Two recent large developments have been submitted for planning approval recently. Both required extensive use of SimScale to model the impact of trees and balustrades as porous media entities to mitigate uncomfortable wind conditions.

New Developments Analyzed for Wind Comfort

Fossetts Farm: The Proposed Development – Scope of Hybrid Application

A hybrid application has been made for part full and part outline planning permission for phased development for:

  • The relocation of Southend United Football Club (SUFC) at Fossetts Farm, Southend-on-Sea, comprising of a 16,226-seat football stadium
  • Creation of up to 1,503 residential units
  • 3,658.10 m2 of mixed Class E floorspace
  • 2,280 m2 of generic floorspace, and up to 280 m2 of mixed Class F1/F2 floorspace (outline)
  • The construction of two Soccer Domes with associated ancillary facilities (1,680 m2 total floorspace of which 275 m2 floor space in community use by SUCET and 1,405 m2 floor space in use by SUFC)
  • Associated landscaping, access and parking works
  • Associated demolition of training center and clubhouse
fossetts farm proposed master plan
Proposed master plan for Fossetts Farm
fossetts farm 3d model
3D model of the Fossetts Farm development including stadium on the right
3d model of stadium at fossetts farm
3D model of the stadium at Fossetts Farm

A microclimate – pedestrian wind comfort (PWC) analysis has been undertaken by SRE to accompany the Fossetts Farm New Hybrid Application, in order to ascertain the impact and the potential effect of the proposed development on pedestrian comfort with respect to wind velocity. The microclimate report builds on the previous microclimate studies that have been undertaken to date by SRE on the Fossetts Farm outline (see masterplan above) and Drop-in Reserved Matters planning applications. All calculations followed the BRE Guide “Wind Microclimate Around Buildings” (DG 530), using the Lawson comfort scale as outputs.

12 wind directions have been analyzed to provide a robust study and the results have been normalized against hourly weather data for different seasons and for the whole year in order to give a thorough comparison against the Lawson Comfort Criteria. In SimScale, all 12 wind directions are simulated in parallel, saving considerable time and computational resources. Wind comfort was considered throughout the detailed design stages, including dedicated design workshops with stakeholders to ensure suitable measures are incorporated into the design to address any concerns regarding microclimate effects. Trees inside the Application Site have been modeled based on the landscape design, as porous media entities along with the balustrades and railings on the accessible roof terraces.

annual wind comfort results
Annual wind comfort results
wind comfort results football stadium
Wind comfort results in and around the football stadium
wind comfort results in winter
Wind comfort results in winter, showing results on roof terraces and balconies (green)

SimScale is a robust tool undergoing continuous development and new features being added all the time. The software comes with great support, saving us huge amounts of time when we are trying to meet strict project timelines. Before using SimScale we used to spend a few days of work just setting up simulations and post-processing the results. SimScale does this for us in a few seconds and provides transient wind simulations which are even more useful. I work on UK projects remotely and the capability to collaborate on a simulation project using the cloud-native features in SimScale has been fantastic.

Nikolaos Protogeros

Head of Building Physics at SRE

Cambridge Road Estate

The Microclimate – Pedestrian Comfort Analysis has been undertaken by SRE to accompany the planning application of the Proposed Development at Cambridge Road Estate, Burritt Road, Kingston Upon Thames, in order to ascertain the impact and the potential effect of the Proposed Development on pedestrian comfort with respect to wind velocity.

The Proposed Development

The Cambridge Road Estate development is located in the Norbiton area of the Royal Borough of Kingston Upon Thames (RBKuT), close to Kingston Town Centre and to the north of the Kingston Cemetery and Crematorium. The existing site, The Cambridge Road Estate (CRE), hosts the largest concentration of Council housing in RBKuT. Currently, 832 homes are located here on the 8.6 hectares site comprising a mix of high-rise blocks, lower-rise flats, and maisonette blocks as well as terraced houses. The immediate surrounding area in general comprises low to medium height buildings. The proposed development of the estate is predominantly residential, with community uses, retail and workspaces, and some ground floor spaces. There is an extensive new public realm with landscaped gardens, pedestrianized areas, and on-street car and cycle parking.

cambridge road estate proposed master plan
Proposed master plan for Cambridge Road Estate

The site area is 88,556 m2 and the masterplan provides 2,170 residential units with 14 different blocks spread across the site. Phase 1 – Blocks B and E are buildings located on the southeastern boundary of the site.

proposed development with and without trees as wind mitigtation
Proposed development without (left) and with (right) trees as wind mitigation measures
podium close up
The podium close up
podium with and without mitigation measure
The podium proposed (left) and with mitigation measures (right) showing lesser annual average wind speeds

Using SimScale, SRE conducted two wind studies. The first was for detailed planning for specific buildings with trees to act as wind mitigation measures on the ground and balconies. Balustrades were also added and wind conditions in courtyard areas were evaluated. The second larger study was for the entire development under four scenarios:

  1. Existing site with existing surrounding buildings
  2. Proposed Development with existing surrounding buildings
  3. Proposed Development with mitigation measures and existing surrounding buildings
  4. Proposed Development with the detailed phase 1 of the redevelopment with mitigation measures and existing surrounding buildings

16 wind directions have been analyzed to provide a robust study and the results have been normalized against hourly weather data for different seasons and the whole year in order to give a thorough comparison against the Lawson comfort criteria. Trees inside the application site have been modeled based on the landscape design, as porous media entities along with the balustrades and railings on the accessible roof terraces and balconies.

pwc annual analysis of existing site
PWC annual analysis of the existing site
pwc annual analysis with mitigation measures
PWC annual analysis of the proposed site with mitigation measures 
annual pwc of existing, proposed, and proposed with mitigation
Annual pedestrian wind comfort comparison of existing (left), proposed (center), and proposed with mitigation measures (right).
Transient wind study animation of the proposed site with trees as mitigation measures

Set up your own cloud-native simulation via the web in minutes by creating an account on the SimScale platform. No installation, special hardware or credit card is required.

Have you considered the potential a cloud-native simulation platform could bring to your organization? Learn about SimScale